Side by side

Buttondown vs Mailchimp

Buttondown: Newsletter service with a free tier for the first 100 subscribers. Mailchimp: Hosted email marketing service with a free plan limited to 250 contacts.

Based on their own pages and documentation on the read dates below. No hands-on test was run for this page.

Facts, side by side

Each value with its source and read date.
FactButtondownMailchimp
Free tierNothing is charged for the first 100 subscribers.
Pricing page, read 2026-11-16
Not read
Billing basisThe page says it charges for active subscribers and assumes at most one email a day to the whole list.
Pricing page, read 2026-11-16
Not read
Add-on priceTagging and segmentation is an add-on at +$9 per month; automations are +$29 per month.
Pricing, read 2026-11-16
Not read
Import from MailchimpThree routes: Connect Mailchimp button, subscriber CSV export, or campaign ZIP file.
Docs, Mailchimp, read 2026-11-16
Not read
Concierge migrationThe home page offers concierge migration of a whole list within one business day.
Home page, read 2026-11-16
Not read
APIThe home page says its API is feature-complete.
Home page, read 2026-11-16
Not read
PriceFree for the first 100 subscribers; tagging and segmentation is a $9 per month add-on, automations $29 per month.
Pricing, read 2026-11-16
Free plan at 0 euro per month for up to 250 contacts; Essentials and Standard were shown only with a 12-month promotional price.
Pricing, read 2026-11-16
LicenseProprietary hosted service; the terms forbid reverse engineering it.
Terms of Service, read 2026-11-16
Proprietary hosted service: the terms state that Mailchimp owns all property rights in the Service.
Mailchimp Terms of Use, read 2026-11-16
HostingHosted service run by Buttondown.
Pricing, read 2026-11-16
Hosted service run by Mailchimp.
Pricing, read 2026-11-16
Free planNot readFree plan shown at 0 euro per month on the French pricing page.
Pricing page, read 2026-11-16
Free plan limitsNot readLimit of 250 contacts; maximum 500 sends per month or 250 per day.
Pricing page, read 2026-11-16
Paid planNot readEssentials and Standard are listed with a 15% discount for the first 12 months.
Pricing, read 2026-11-16
ExportNot readAn entire audience, a segment, a tag or a group can be exported as CSV; the export may come as a ZIP file.
Help, export contacts, read 2026-11-16
Export scopeNot readContact exports do not include email report data such as open and click rates; exports stay in the account for 30 days.
Help, export contacts, read 2026-11-16
ImportNot readContacts can be imported from 6 connected apps, from a CSV or TXT file, or pasted from a spreadsheet; the email address column is required.
Help, import contacts, read 2026-11-16
Last verificationRead 2026-11-16Read 2026-11-16

What each one gives up

Buttondown

Free plan
  • No base paid price is stated, so no entry price is shown.
  • Tagging and automations are paid add-ons.

Mailchimp

Free plan
  • Contact exports exclude email report data such as open and click rates.
  • The free plan stops at 250 contacts.

Who each one is for

Buttondown

Not written yet.

Buttondown facts and sources

Mailchimp

Not written yet.

Mailchimp facts and sources

Frequently asked questions

Was either tool tested by hand?

No hands-on test was run for this page. Every value comes from the tools' own pages and documentation, with its read date.

Is there a winner?

No. The page lists what each one gives up and who each one is for. There is no score and no rank.

What does “Not read” mean?

We have no source for that fact yet. It is left empty rather than guessed.

How do I correct a fact?

Write to hello@alternatives.directory with the source. The fact is re-read and its date updated.